The Oldest
Originally published 2026-08-27 on The Edge of Now: https://thombarrett.substack.com/p/the-oldest
As I sit here now, I can’t remember a time I didn’t have a side hustle. Some I chose. Some got chosen for me — and once in a while I chose my way out of those, too.
When I was eight or nine, I ran a paper route — though "paper route" undersells what it was.
I didn’t deliver the Detroit Free Press door to door like the other kids. I went after the thing nobody else wanted: the advertising circulars that were just then becoming a fixture of the Sunday paper, the fat bundle of flyers most people threw away without reading. Somebody had to get them onto every porch, and I worked out that the somebody could be me. The flyers were dropped at our house in stacks — I couldn’t drive, so the route had to come to me — and I turned my younger brothers and sisters into a production line, rolling each one and snapping a rubber band around it while I loaded the finished bundles into the canvas bag they gave me. Then I’d sling the bag over the handlebars and go, and after a few weeks I’d taught myself to pedal, steer, and throw all at once, laying a flyer on each porch without stopping.
When it rained, my mother drove. She’d idle the car down the street and I’d run alongside it in the wet, reaching in the window to grab the next bundle and throw it, house after house, because it did not occur to me that rain was a reason to stop. The route was mine. Mine meant it got done.
Not every hustle was for money. My father ran dance classes at a set of studios, and he’d bring me along and put me to work — sweeping the floors, cleaning the bathrooms, whatever needed doing while the class ran in the next room without me. I didn’t mind work. I minded work that did nothing for me, and mopping a floor while music played on the other side of the wall was, by my accounting even then, a poor use of an afternoon. So one day I set down the broom, walked in, and started taking the class with everyone else. Tap, ballet, jazz. My father didn’t say a word. He just raised an eyebrow — and to this day I couldn’t tell you whether what he was hiding behind it was a smile or a smirk.
I’ve thought about that kid a lot lately, because he explains more of me than I’m entirely comfortable with. He was the oldest of six — I was born in 1956, and the others came about every two years after, down to a brother young enough that I’d changed his diapers before I had a learner’s permit. Ten years, six kids. Being the oldest of that many, that fast, installs exactly two things in a person, and it took me most of my life to notice that only one of them ever actually arrived.
The one that arrived was ownership. Not the having of things — the owning of them, in the sense of being the person answerable for whether they worked. My parents were out most nights. My father was a musician; he played piano in the evenings and ran dance studios by day, and in the summers he’d go on tour to the Poconos as a warm-up act for the kind of entertainers who headlined those camps. Somebody had to run the house while the grown-ups ran their lives, and that somebody was me, by default, before anyone thought to ask whether I wanted the job. You don’t get asked. The oldest never gets asked. The responsibilities arrive already assigned, and your only real choice is to pick them up or let the whole thing fall — and I was not built to let things fall.
So I ran it. Dinner was the center of the operation — my mother usually left something arranged, and I cooked it, got everyone to the table, and ran the cleanup after. Most nights it worked. One night it spectacularly didn’t. It had been a chaotic day, nobody was listening to me, and the food was going cold while I tried to herd five kids into their chairs. I finally lost it and yelled at them to get your asses in the room. The two youngest took me at my word. They climbed onto the deck outside the dining room, dropped their pants, and mooned me through the glass.
I have never forgotten it, because it was both genuinely funny and genuinely infuriating, and those two things sitting on top of each other are the whole of what it is to be the oldest. You have all of the responsibility and none of the power. You are answerable for the dinner and the dishes and whether everyone is alive at the end of the night, and a small child with his bare backside pressed to a window gets to decide, in real time, whether any of your authority means a thing. It doesn’t, is the answer. Not really. You hold the job without the standing. You just do it anyway, because someone has to, and you’re the someone.
That was the face of ownership I wore most nights — dutiful, unglamorous, faintly ridiculous. But it had a harder face too, and I found it the night I threw someone out of the house.
There was a boy living with us at the time — the details aren’t entirely mine to lay out, but my parents were weighing whether to take him in permanently, and as they did his older brother. The brother had been bullying one of my sisters. I learned about it at the dinner table, with him sitting right there, and I did not wait for my parents to handle it or even consult them. I told him to leave. I told him I didn’t care where he went, but that he was not welcome in the house again, and he wasn’t. I was a kid overruling a decision two adults were still in the middle of making, expelling a near-member of the family on my own authority, because one of mine was being hurt and I had decided that settled it.
I tell that story now and I can see both things in it at once: how completely I’d absorbed the idea that these people were mine to protect, and how little it occurred to me that any of it was above my pay grade. Ownership, at its fullest, is exactly that — the refusal to wait for permission when something you’re responsible for is on the line. I had it in surplus. I have had it in surplus my whole life. It is the single most reliable thing about me.
The other thing being the oldest was supposed to install never showed up. I did not have empathy. It was not that I was cruel, or cold, or indifferent to the people around me. It was simpler and stranger than that: what another person was feeling did not enter the calculation. It was not on the board. I could run five kids like a shift supervisor and never once check the interior of any of them, because running people and feeling them are different faculties, and the job had trained the first to a fine edge while leaving the second blank.
The clearest picture I have of that blank is a small tragedy involving a rodent.
We weren’t allowed animals in the house, apart from the dog — my mother had named him Patience, on the theory that no one in the family had any, so at least she could summon some by calling the dog. But one week my siblings and I found a small animal outside; we decided it was a gerbil, though I learned much later it was almost certainly a vole. Naturally, we built it a house. Not a box — a structure, multiple stories, with a running wheel for exercise and a bowl for food, engineered with real care. When a second animal turned up a few days later, we expanded the thing to hold more of them, imagining a whole population of tenants. For a week we fed them and watched them and were, all of us, quietly delighted.
Then one morning they were gone. We had built the animals a running wheel and a feeding station and a second wing, and had not built them a floor, so they had simply dug down through the open bottom and left. My brothers and sisters were distraught — real grief, the kind small children feel wholesale. And my response, standing in front of their tears, was to blow the structure up.
I’d like to tell you I comforted them first. I didn’t. The habitat was now a habitat for nothing, a failed build sitting uselessly in the yard, and I did what I did with a failed build: I got rid of it, decisively, with the chemistry I loved more than almost anything at that age. It genuinely did not occur to me that what the moment called for was for me to sit down in their sadness with them. The animals were gone; the structure was obsolete; I removed the obsolete structure. That my sisters cried harder at the explosion than at the escape was, at the time, a piece of data I could not interpret.
I understand it now, forty-some years late. I met a feeling with an engineering problem, because a feeling was not a thing I knew how to hold and an engineering problem was. That is the whole shape of my empathy gap, and I have since watched myself run the identical move at every scale my life has offered. Handed grief, I have reached for a task. Handed a thing I could not fix in someone else, I have gone and built or dismantled something I could. The kid with the detonator and the man I became are not two people. He was the first draft of a way of handling the world that has served me brilliantly with problems and failed me, over and over, with people.
Those two things — the ownership I had in surplus and the empathy I did not have at all — spent my childhood mostly running in parallel. But they collided once, hard enough that I still feel the bruise, on the day I missed the state championships.
I was a serious athlete as a kid — track, soccer, basketball; I was among the best in the state in the triple jump and the high hurdles. I had qualified for the state meet, three hours away in Amherst, and there was a bus taking the team. There were also chores. My father held that the chores came first because the chores were mine, and mine came first, and by the time the argument was over the bus was gone. I remember being out in the yard afterward doing one of those chores and crying while I did it — still doing the chore, because the chore did not stop just because I was falling apart. My father came out and saw me crying and asked what was wrong, but not the way you ask when you are worried. He asked the way you ask when a kid’s crying is an irritation you would like resolved.
When I told him I had missed the bus to the state meet, he asked why I hadn’t told him. I had told him. He had made me do the chores anyway. Something must have finally landed, because he dropped everything and drove me the three hours to Amherst himself — a real effort, and I have never doubted the love in it. We arrived after the meet was over. I did not run a single one of the events I had qualified for. The effort came. It just came too late to matter, which I have come to think is the most honest thing love sometimes manages.
I have thought about that afternoon more as I have gotten older. I had become the kind of kid who owned everything — his training, his logistics, his own way to the meet — precisely because no one was going to carry any of it for me; the household had taught me that nothing gets handled unless I handle it. And that same arrangement is exactly what cost me the thing I loved, because when the duty and the dream finally collided, the duty won, and I did not have the power to overrule it. The ownership and the caretaking were not cause and effect. They were two things one childhood demanded at once, and that was the day they could not both be satisfied, and I was the one who paid the difference. It would not be the last time.
And there is the other thing in that frame, the one I only saw much later: my father, perturbed at my crying, treating the feeling as a disruption rather than a thing to feel alongside me. I learned the grammar of that early. I am not proud of how fluent I became in it.
At seventeen, I was going to stay. Not give up — stay. Continue. We had landed on Cape Cod after Detroit, and by then my father was a builder; he had put up a business, Barrett and Sons, and folded the boys into it. I knew how to work with my hands. I knew the Cape. The life was already half-constructed around me, and taking it up felt less like a choice than like not interrupting something already in motion. Then a man across the lake named Eddie Miller — who turned out to be the public relations director at Boston College, and very good at his job — handed me two tickets to a football game and, without ever once telling me what to do, arranged for me to spend an afternoon being shown what a life I hadn’t considered might look like. I went to Boston College. Everything I became came through that door.
It looked, for years, like simply the good decision.
My father lost a builder and a pair of hands, and something more than that — a son who might have taken the business somewhere. We were never close enough for me to know what it cost him; that distance was its own quiet fact, and I won’t pretend to have read it. Several of my brothers and sisters followed the path I had cut — one of them to the same college, into the same courses — because the oldest does not get to make a private decision. Whatever I did became the template, the way the dinner table and the paper route had been, except now the thing I was organizing them into was a whole different life.
And the youngest of us was eight when I left. He never finished high school. He worked for my father, and he is, at sixty, a carpenter still — and much later in his life I understood that he had quietly carried, for decades, the belief that I had deserted the family. That I had walked out on all of it. He was not wrong to feel it. The oldest who cooked their dinners and ran their nights and threw a boy out of the house to protect one of them — left. From where an eight-year-old stood, watching the person who had been running things pack up for Boston, that reads as exactly what he came to believe it was. I had been the one who stayed and handled it. And then I was the one who went.
I did it again at forty-four. I left a marriage, and the daily architecture of my daughters’ childhood, because I had come to feel I could not become who I needed to become inside it. And I made that decision, as I had made the one at seventeen, without fully weighing what it would cost the people on the other side of it — until much later, when the weighing arrives whether you invited it or not.
For a long time I told myself a simple, punishing story about all of this: that the leaving proved I had no heart. That a man who could walk away from a family business and then a family must be missing something essential. I don’t tell it that way anymore, because it is not true, and the untruth of it matters.
Leaving was not the failure. Needing my own life was not the crime. People leave paths that were never theirs, and leave marriages they cannot stay whole inside, and it can be the right thing and even, sometimes, the kind one — I gave my daughters more of myself in the years after than I think I would have managed had I stayed and slowly disappeared inside a life that was ending. I did not leave my daughters. I left a marriage. The distinction is not a loophole; it is the truth.
What I am actually accountable for is narrower and harder than "I left." It is the blindness. Both times, the cost to the people I was leaving did not enter the calculation in real time, the way my sisters’ grief did not enter it in front of the exploded habitat. That is the thing I own — not the having of needs, but the failure to see, while I acted on them, what they would do to someone else. I have spent thirty years learning to see it. The empathy that never arrived when I was the oldest of six is the one faculty I have built entirely by hand, late, and on purpose — and the only reason I can describe any of this clearly now is that I finally have the instrument I was missing the whole time it would have helped.
So that is the oldest of six, as honestly as I can draw him. A kid who could run anything and feel almost nothing, who owned every problem he touched and missed nearly every person inside those problems, who protected his siblings ferociously and then became the thing they had to survive. It is not a flattering portrait, and I have stopped trying to pretty it up. But I have also stopped charging myself for the wrong crime. I was not heartless. I was blind — and blindness, unlike a cold heart, is something a person can spend the rest of his life learning to correct. I have been at it a while now. I can see the boy in the yard, crying and still doing the chores, and for the first time I know exactly what he was feeling. That is not nothing. It might, in the end, be the whole point.


Comments